Abundance or Control
We have an opportunity for abundance. A glory period for humanity. We could cure diseases and make more creative works of art than ever before. Everyone can win.
Is it really so bad if we don’t have to work? Is your job the thing that fulfills you? That’s an insane thought when you could do whatever you want. Spend time with your children. Mow your lawn. Cook pancakes for your family.
That future isn’t guaranteed. It depends on who controls the technology, and right now a small group of fear-mongering villains is fighting hard to make sure it’s them. Just look at this week.
On Tuesday, Anthropic launched Sheets, Whiteboards and Claude Data, the product that used to be called Dashboards. It also announced Claude Meetings, a companion that joins your calls. Its IPO is now five days away. This is the company whose CEO has promised that AI will cure Alzheimer’s, heart disease, cancer and all that. Instead, it’s launching a SaaS replacement for Microsoft.
Then Microsoft itself went down. On Thursday, Microsoft 365 had an outage that lasted more than 24 hours. On Friday, the FAA stopped flights across the US. Microsoft says its outage was a technical problem, not a cyberattack. The FAA blames an equipment issue during a network upgrade. Oddly convenient.
Remember, this is the same month Bill Gates warned, without any substantial evidence, that we’ll soon face a crisis worse than COVID, and that it will come from AI: AI-made bioweapons, AI hacking and all that. Now two of the biggest systems in the US go down in the same week, and there’s no AI involved, allegedly. To me, it’s as clear as day: this was most likely AI. The FAA had expanded an AI air traffic management system only days earlier, and it denies that system played any part. Microsoft still hasn’t published a root cause. AI is a threat when it justifies control, and never the cause when something actually breaks.
On the same Thursday, Jensen Huang was pushed out of NVIDIA. Jensen was the frontrunner for open source. Anthropic, meanwhile, is the company against open source. OpenAI probably is too, and perhaps the entire effective altruism industrial complex: people who think they’re so much smarter than everyone else that they can control everyone.
Put the names together: Reid Hoffman, Bill Gates, Dario Amodei, Dustin Moskovitz and the effective altruism crowd. That’s the left wing of control. They want one thing: regulatory capture, with the models locked into a duopoly between Anthropic and OpenAI. It looks horrible. Perhaps they’re not evil people, and they just don’t see what they’re doing. But their acts are evil, and against the greater good of humanity.
At least, that’s what their actions are telling me. They don’t care about money. They want power. They want to control the media, the narrative and the information. It reminds me an awful lot of the USSR, and of the Nazi book burnings.
Let me tell you why I’m so passionate about this. We’re building Oplema. I hope it becomes my life’s work. It isn’t yet, but it’s already the thing I’ve spent the most time on in my life. And we’re building it on top of their models.
We use vendors on top of vendors, like OpenRouter, which hosts Anthropic’s models and a lot of other models that are pretty good. We won’t be able to exist if we have to ask for permission to use certain models. We can’t use an Anthropic model at 100 times the current price, restricted in what it can say.
We need competition, both in the model layer and in the data center layer. We run on Hetzner. Who’s to say they won’t come after that too? We can’t have one company delivering all the SaaS in the world. Sure, they can deliver the API. It’s their own fault they chose a business where the margins are heading to zero. That doesn’t mean they have to act evil and try to control everything built on top of it.
And if they’re worried about AI hacking, secure your products better. That’s what we’re doing right now. Everyone needs to chill, let people cook and believe in it.
So this isn’t the rich against the poor. It’s the takers against the makers. The controllers, who think of us as ants, against the free thinkers, the creatives and the engineers. It’s the good against the evil, and it feels like the last battle.
We have to fight back. We have to get Jensen back. We have to win this.
And I’ll tell you this right now: the good wins. We have the smart people, and the smart usually win against the less smart.
I’ll leave you with a quote:
Who controls the past controls the future: who controls the present controls the past.
George Orwell, Nineteen Eighty-Four (source)